I hear a commotion from where I stand at the kitchen sink. There is a scurry of feet, a pounding at the steps, and then a few quick taps from one excited little hand.
I look down to find a bouncing H. His mouth is open wide, and he points urgently to his two front lower incisors.
“They’re wiggly!” he shouts and then bounces some more.
“They are?!” I say. “Well, buddy, that’s great!” I ask him to stop hopping so I can check out his teeth for myself. Sure enough, they’re as wiggly as worms.
I’m happy for two reasons. First, my kindergartener—who walked at 10 months and spoke full sentences by his first birthday—is one of the last kids in his class to drop a few pearly whites. The delay has turned into a point of stress for my kiddo; lately, I’ve caught him with a furrowed brow and two plier-like fingers in his mouth. Often.
I’m also excited because I’ve never played the role of Tooth Fairy. It smacks soundly of a new 36×37 assignment. I’m thankful for that because it will replace what was supposed to be assignment #33 – Learn to Change a Tire.
H pokes through one of our many “junk” drawers and pulls out the Tooth Fairy pillow my mom gave him a few months ago. “I can finally use this!” he says, flashing a smile that will one day soon be two teeth short.
~*~
Now, I don’t know about you, but some of the people I know get competitive about certain things, like where they went on their last spa vacation, or what luxury car they plan to buy this summer. The habit extends all the way down the rank and file, because some parents in H’s class have forked over $20 per tooth, and their kids have talked about it with their friends. “That’s preposterous,” I think. “They’re baby teeth, for crying out loud.” And besides all that, H has 20 teeth to lose. Do we really need to invest $400 in this enterprise, when a $20 total sounds much more intelligent?
I take the question to my friends via facebook: “How much coin is the Tooth Fairy dropping these days?” I ask. My friends give reasonable answers: One to two dollars seems to be the going rate.
I dwell and dwell and dwell on this. Ordinarily, I wouldn’t, but look at it this way: If I take the reasonable route, will H come home and ask why the Tooth Fairy gave him $1, while Joe received a cool, green Jackson? If yes, what answer will I give—that the Tooth Fairy donated the other $19 to his college fund?
So I dwell some more. In fact, I dwell so much that I do something really stupid.
“I ran into Scott at the store,” I tell GB. “I told him H has two loose teeth, and asked him his opinion on the going Tooth Fairy rate. He said he gave his kids $20 for each tooth. I told him I thought that was crazy!”
I notice a strange look cross GB’s face. Then I remember where I am and what I’m doing: standing at the boys’ bathroom sink, helping H brush his tiny chompers.
Oh no.
H looks at me quizzically. “$20 per tooth?” he asks.
I give him a hug to hide my face while I back pedal. “That was a long time ago…” I say eventually. “Mr. Scott’s kids are teenagers now. I don’t think the Tooth Fairy gives away that much change anymore. You know. Because of the Recession.”
I look at GB who shakes his head and laughs. “Good work,” I tell myself. “You’ve just added another idiot move to your growing collection.”
~*~
We spend the next few days doing everything we can think of to extract the wigglier of the two teeth. H takes to apples. Steak. Hard candy. Rigorous brushing. In the end, GB takes matters into his own hands—literally. It’s a quick and painless yank, and H is ecstatic.
He slides the tooth into the pocket of the Tooth Fairy pillow then places it under the cool side of his blue and red pillow case.
“You might not want to shove it under so far,” I say. “I’ll bet the Tooth Fairy is about Tinkerbelle’s size; the pillow might be hard for her to lift.”
H nods appreciatively at my advice and slides the tiny pillow to the edge of the bed.
“I should go to sleep!” he says. “I don’t want to be awake when she gets here!”
“Good thinking,” I say.
“You should get to sleep, too, Mama,” he says. “I don’t want you to ruin this for me.”
“I wouldn’t think of it,” I say.
Fifteen minutes later, my boy is in Snoozetown. Already he has turned away from his pillow to assist the transaction. Carefully, I swipe the tooth for the cash. When I retreat from his room on my tiptoes, I realize I’ve been holding my breath.
In the morning, I wake to find H snuggled warmly against my side. He’s reluctant to open his eyes until I remind him about his nighttime visitor. He rushes to his room, casts aside all pillows and blankets and finds two gold $1 coins where his tooth used to be.
Based on his new jack-o-lantern smile, it is exactly enough.
~*~ Find me on Twitter @37×37
~*~Visit the 36×37 facebook page


Awesome work, M.
Thanks, Jason!
My girl is 12 now, and we gave $2 for the first tooth, and $1 to $2 depending on how much cash we had on hand at the time! LOL! I got where I kept 3 or 4 dollar bills laying around so I would have them in case I needed them.
That’s a good tip, Bonnie. We found another wiggly tooth this morning, so I have a feeling we’ll have to start keeping cash on hand, too.
That’s awesome. What an adorable jack o’ lantern smile on that face. It’s worth every penny.
My daughter, mother to Hoo,as a tot was too afraid to imagine even a friendly fairy coming to put cold hard cash under her pillow at night so I would handle all the fairy and Claus transactions for her.
She would come to me with my purse in the morning for the handout.
Nothing new under the sun.
My husband says we could just take out one of our windows and put in an ATM machine and our kids would never even have to come into the house.
Great story awesome post and beautiful family!!!
Thanks, Gmom! I like your husband’s ATM idea. I wonder why nobody markets a product like the home ATM? See a need and fill it, right?
Oh dear, Gmom…I hope my kids never see your comment about the home ATM!
Loved this post, Maura! Wait until the time when you have to explain to them that the tooth fairy “forgot”!
I’d pick being the Tooth Fairy over changing a tire any day!
Hugs,
Wendy
P.S. $2 is just fine…maybe $20 is the going rate in a city like Los Angeles…
Ha! That’s awesome, Wendy. Did you forget once?
I hope I’m not coming down too hard on folks who do fork over that $20. It’s all a matter of budget, I completely understand that.
Once??? I wish! I’ve got three girls…the Tooth Fairy definitely forgot more than once!
Good luck!
Wendy
Perfectly done, Mom. Er, Tooth Fairy.
My husband and I shudder to think on all the perceived short-comings our dear children will endure because of their parents inability to be influenced by peer-comparisons.
Already we’ve refused Disneyworld and are instead building up the romance and intrigue of historic Colonial Williamsburg instead…
(We tell ourselves it’s working:))
(!!!) Colonial Williamsburg! Your family will love it, Erika! I hope when you go you’ll post about it.
Great post! I love that you found a way around the Jones’ with gold coins (not that there is anything wrong with the Jones’; nice enough people I bet). You sure had me in suspense until the end, and did not see the gold coins coming. Way cooler than any paper bill
Thanks so much, Country Wife. I can’t take credit for the gold $1 coins–GB tracked them down for the occasion.
I didn’t even know they existed.
Ah, what a sweet post! The gold coins were a brilliant idea, Maura. But, I’m with you–$20 is an outrage! Lord have mercy—————
Kathy
Thanks, Kathy! Really, at this age, kids would be just as happy with Monopoly money.
Great job Maura – another milestone completed! I am glad you started low because as you pointed out, it could be a darn fortune when all is said and done. We kept it low unless they had to have a tooth pulled. Just a little more to ease the pain!
Have a great day!
Well, I think you’re right, Paula. Pulled teeth deserve a few extra bucks plus a bowl of ice cream.
“I don’t want you to ruin this for me” — HAHAHAHAHAHAH! That made me laugh out loud! That’s one of those “just wait until you have kids of your own H” moments!
Good job. $20 for a tooth is absurd, and I don’t care if I DO offend the Jones Family (although if they’d like to invest in a future winery, I can put them in contact with someone).
LOL. Well you know, the Jones’ do like to talk about their trips to Napa…
$20 is crazy. Once, we forgot to put $2 under Thing 2′s pillow. She was crushed. I went into her room, said it just had to be there and “found” $2 behind the bed.
She didn’t buy it.
Ha! Smart girl. (Good luck with those teenage years.)
The Tooth Fairy works in wonderful and mysterious ways. The gold coins were perfect. With the coins and the missing teeth, H only needs and eye patch and he’d make a perfect pirate.
I might yank my own teeth out for $20 per tooth.
No kidding, right? I wish I’d thought of that idea myself, Jacquelin. If I pulled every tooth in my head, and the Tooth Fairy gave me a $20 for each one, I’d have almost enough money for a straight pair of false teeth–no adult braces required.
Love the gold coin idea and the adorable toothless picture!
I forgot once with Kitty Cat. She showed up bedside just before dawn. Dangit! I told her she was too early to rise and needed to give the tooth fairy more time. Then all I had was a $5. Very bad precedent to set. Lesson learned. Be all over the tooth fairy thing or pay through the nose.
Ha! I love that Kitty Cat scored some extra dough. Good reminder, though, that I should start stocking up. Now one of H’s top incisors feels wiggly, too…
Kids make great blog fodder, don’t they?
Without kids, I’d have written no more than five posts this year.
What fun! Good job, TF! The gold coins were a nice touch. Congrats on your son’s first tooth loss. I remember him pointing out the tooth on your journey to Sandusky.
Our oldest (also in K) began losing his teeth recently, too. The tooth fairy had to borrow money from the kids’ piggy bank, as the tooth loss was unexpected.
He accidentally swallowed his latest loose tooth over the weekend. He never even asked about the Tooth Fairy.
LOL! Oh, your little guy! Big congrats to him and to the Tooth Fairy, too!
Coins were a perfect idea! Such a sweet story…from a good storyteller.
Thanks so much, Tracy!
The tooth fairy certainly presents more philosophical questions than Santa. It’s harder for kids to compare the dollar value of the presents they get at Christmas, but it’s pretty easy to compare getting $1 for a tooth versus getting $20.
See, this is why we shouldn’t teach math before all big boy teeth are in place.
Loved this, Maura. The family portrait made me smile because my youngest son always made a face or something every single time we got a family picture.
We gave out $1 bills more than 20 years ago, so I’m glad to hear people are still keeping things in perspective. The gold coins were genius! I got a bunch of them as change at the Metro and took them to the bank because I kept mistaking them for quarters.
Awwww…love the missing tooth pic! He pulled it out? I was never able to do that…even when it was barely hanging on.
Haha, this was so cute. Both my parents smoke (ridiculous amounts when I was a kid), so whenever the “tooth fairy” came, there seemed to be ashes left behind. I always wondered why in the world the tooth fairy would smoke! It can’t be good for your teeth! It all made sense when I figured it out.
We don’t have tooth fairies in our part of the world and what with $20 a tooth I for one am not complaining! Your post took me back to when I was H’s age and terrified of losing my teeth! Is it a girl thing do you think?
I remember my Dad pulling out a tooth once while I stood and yelled my lungs out in front of the sink! I would have kept up with the yelling too, if he hadn’t calmed me down enough to show me the offending tooth in his hand…the one he had plucked out 5 minutes before!
Great tooth fairy story. I’m with you: 2 gold coins sounds perfect. I’ve been “brushing up” (haha) on tooth fairy information since we’ll probably be expecting a visit soon… our 3 year old son will very likely be getting an injured tooth extracted. (By the way, I found this Mom’s Guide to be helpful in dealing with our dental woes.) So as a premature first time tooth fairy I’m going to need all the help I can get! Such a sweet photo of your little man, too. I’m guessing a leaving-the-dentist-crying photo will not be as cute.
He must have the cutest look as he opened his tooth pocket! It must be pretty exciting doing a tooth fairy role, huh? I remember when my Mama said that Tooth Fairy collects milk teeth to give to those toothless children on her fairyland. I thought then, that tooth fairy is the greatest for doing such charity to make every child have the most beautiful smile. And I bet H had the greatest one too, that day.